If the job is finished apart from snags, the customer owes you the price, less what it would cost to put the snags right. Holding back the whole final payment over a sticking door and a gap in the sealant goes further than the law does. They can ask you to come back and fix faults in your work at your own cost, and offering to do that quickly is usually the fastest way to your money. It's different if the work doesn't do its job: heating that doesn't heat isn't a snag, and you may not be owed the rest until it's fixed.

This is a guide for trades working for private customers in the UK, not legal advice. It follows the law in England and Wales; contract law in Scotland differs in places.

A snag, or a job that doesn't work?

Snags are the small things at the end: a door that sticks, a gap in the sealant, a scuff on the paintwork, a socket plate that isn't straight. The job still does what it was for. A job that doesn't work is a different thing: a leak, a boiler that won't fire, a shower with no pressure.

Lawyers still quote two old cases that show the difference:

  • The decorator who got paid. He finished a £750 job decorating and furnishing a flat, with £55 of faults in a wardrobe and a bookcase. The Court of Appeal said he was owed the full price, less the £55 (Hoenig v Isaacs, 1952).
  • The heating engineer who didn't. He fitted £560 of central heating that gave off fumes and left the house cold. Putting it right would have cost £174. He was owed nothing, because, the court said, the job hadn't really been done (Bolton v Mahadeva, 1972).

What decided it was whether the job did what it was for. The decorator's did. The heating didn't.

What the customer can ask for

Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, you have to do the work with reasonable care and skill. Where you haven't:

  • They can ask you to put it right. You do it at your own cost, labour and materials, within a reasonable time and without too much hassle for them.
  • They can ask for money off if putting it right is impossible, or you didn't do it in a reasonable time. In a bad case, that can be the whole price.
  • They can point to the faults when you ask to be paid. That's the legal footing for "I'll pay when it's fixed".

So it's normal for a customer to hold something back until the snags are sorted. The argument is about how much.

How much they can hold back

Roughly what it would cost to put the snags right. On a £6,000 bathroom where the final payment is £1,200 and the snags would take £150 to sort, that's £150, not £1,200.

Walk round with the customer at the end, write the snag list together and agree a date to come back. Then ask for the rest:

"Here's the list we agreed. I'll be back Thursday to sort it. Can you pay £1,050 today, and the last £150 once it's done?"

It's fair, it's in writing, and it shows you're coming back.

If they won't let you back

The customer's first remedy is to have you put it right. Money off comes in when that's impossible or you don't do it in time. So offer to come back, in writing, with dates. If they refuse and get someone else in, keep that message. If it ever goes further, it shows you tried to fix it, and a customer who wouldn't let you is in a weaker position to argue they owe you nothing.

Stop it happening next time

  • Make the last payment small. Split the job so most of the money is paid as the work goes, with a small last stage "on completion of snagging", say 5% of the job. On that £6,000 bathroom, a snag then holds up £300, not £1,200.
  • Say how snags work in your quote. One line does it: "We'll walk round together at the end and agree a snag list. We'll fix it within 7 days, and the final payment is due when it's done."
  • Take photos. Photograph each stage before it's covered up, and the finished job before you leave. Dated photos help settle "it was like that when you left".
  • Check in at each stage. A problem spotted at first fix is easier to sort than one argued about at the end.

With WorkPaid: split the job into stages when you write the quote, and WorkPaid suggests a small snagging stage for the end. So most of the money is in before the snag list starts.

If the customer is a business or a landlord

This guide is about homeowners. If the customer is a business, or a landlord having work done on a property they don't live in, the Construction Act usually applies instead. It doesn't cover work on a home the customer lives in. Under it, a customer who wants to pay less than the amount due generally has to send you a written notice in time (often called a pay less notice), saying how much they'll pay and why. If they don't pay, you can give at least 7 days' notice and stop work, and either of you can take the dispute to adjudication, which normally gives a decision within 28 days. The timings depend on the contract, so get advice before you rely on it.

If they still won't pay

Put it in writing once more: what's owed, the snag list, when you fixed it or offered to, and a date to pay by. If that doesn't work, see whether your trade body runs a dispute service; Citizens Advice points customers there too. The last step is a court claim for money, and the court may offer free mediation first, depending on the amount. If the customer paid by card, they might dispute the payment with their bank instead; how that works is in customer raised a chargeback after the job.

With WorkPaid: add photos to the job as you go. Each one is stamped with the time it reached us, not the phone's own date, and you choose which ones the customer sees. It's free to send quotes, with no monthly fee. Get started free.

Three questions we get asked

Can a customer refuse to pay the final payment because of snags?

Not all of it, if the job is finished apart from snags. They owe the price, less what it would cost to put the snags right. If the work doesn't do its job, like heating that doesn't heat, they may not owe the rest until it's fixed.

How much can a customer hold back for snagging?

Roughly what the snags would cost to put right. Agree the snag list and that amount in writing, ask them to pay the rest now, and they pay the held-back part once you have fixed it.

Do I have to go back and fix snags?

If they're faults in your work, yes. The customer can ask you to put them right at your own cost, within a reasonable time. Offering to come back quickly, in writing, is also your best route to the final payment.

Doing it in WorkPaid

In WorkPaid you can split a job into stages, each with its own name and amount. Make the last one small and call it something like "Final on snagging", and the customer pays most of the job as the work goes. When a stage is done, request it: the customer pays from the link on their phone, and reminders follow if it sits unpaid.

Plan it when you write the quote. Once the customer has paid anything, the payments are fixed, so you can't split a stage or the final payment into "some now, the rest after the snags". If the last payment is a big one, the customer pays it in full once the snags are fixed. When you set up stages, WorkPaid suggests a small snagging stage for the end.

Add photos to the job as you go, or to the stage they show. Each one is stamped with the time it reached us, not the phone's own date, and you choose which ones the customer sees on their quote page. If a customer later says the work was never finished, those photos and the dated record of the quote they accepted are your evidence, whether it's a row over the bill or a card dispute. And if the row is really about what was agreed in the first place, see quote or estimate.

Where this comes from: sections 49, 54, 55 and 56 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015; sections 106, 108, 111 and 112 of the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 (the Construction Act); Hoenig v Isaacs [1952] EWCA Civ 6 and Bolton v Mahadeva [1972] EWCA Civ 5; and Citizens Advice's guide to problems with building work.